brown #
= weekly rock chart peak
blue #
= pop chart peak
| 1 | December, 1963 (Oh, What A Night) | 1 | Mar 1976 |  |
| The Four Seasons |
| 2 | See You In September | 1 | Aug 1966 | |
| The Happenings |
| 3 | December | 1 | 1 | Jul 1995 | |
| Collective Soul |
| 4 | November Rain | 2 | 2 | Aug 1992 | |
| Guns N' Roses |
| 5 | A Long December | 3 | 2 | Jan 1997 | |
| Counting Crows |
| 6 | Wake Me Up When September Ends | 1 | 3 | Oct 2005 | |
| Green Day |
| 7 | Back To December | 17 | Dec 2010 | |
| Taylor Swift |
| 8 | September | 4 | Feb 1979 | |
| Earth, Wind & Fire |
| 9 | September | 14 | Nov 2010 | |
| Daughtry |
| 10 | December, 1963 (Oh, What A Night) | 7 | Oct 1994 | |
| The Four Seasons |
| 11 | It Might As Well Rain Until September | 20 | Sep 1962 | |
| Carole King |
| 12 | September Morn' | 8 | Feb 1980 | |
| Neil Diamond |