brown #
= weekly rock chart peak
blue #
= pop chart peak
| 1 | Time After Time | 1922 |  |
| Henry Burr |
| 2 | Time After Time | 1947 | |
| Frank Sinatra with Nelson Riddle Orchestra |
| 3 | Time After Time | 1947 | |
| Margaret Whiting With Frank DeVol And His Orchestra |
| 4 | Time After Time | 1947 | |
| Tommy Dorsey And His Orchestra with Stuart Foster |
| 5 | Time After Time | Feb 1960 | |
| Frankie Ford |
| 6 | Time After Time | Dec 1966 | |
| Chris Montez |
| 7 | Time After Time | Feb 1980 | |
| The Rockets |
| 8 | Time After Time | 19 | 1 | May 1984 | |
| Cyndi Lauper |
| 9 | Time After Time (AnnElise) | 1984 | |
| R.E.M. |
| 10 | Time After Time | Oct 1986 | |
| Barbara Dickson |
| 11 | Time After Time | 30 | Mar 1990 | |
| Timmy T |
| 12 | Time After Time | Jun 1990 | |
| The Beloved |
| 13 | Time After Time | 2 | Nov 1992 | |
| Ozzy Osbourne |
| 14 | Time After Time | Feb 1993 | |
| Hyperstate |
| 15 | Time After Time | Apr 1998 | |
| Changing Faces |
| 16 | Time After Time | 6 | Sep 1998 | |
| Inoj |
| 17 | Time After Time | Mar 2002 | |
| Distant Soundz |
| 18 | Time After Time | Feb 2003 | |
| Novaspace |
| 19 | Time After Time | Mar 2004 | |
| Rod Stewart |
| 20 | Time After Time | Jun 2004 | |
| Jake Mathews |
| 21 | Time After Time | Dec 2005 | |
| Cyndi Lauper Featuring Sarah McLachlan |
| 22 | Time After Time | Aug 2006 | |
| Spoken |
| 23 | Time After Time | Mar 2007 | |
| Koishii & Hush Featuring Catherine McQueen |
| 24 | Time After Time | 12 | Jul 2007 | |
| Quietdrive |
| 25 | Time After Time | Jun 2008 | |
| Elliot Minor |
| 26 | Time After Time | May 2011 | |
| Javier Colon |
| 27 | Time After Time | Jun 2012 | |
| Eva Cassidy |
| 28 | Time After Time | Jun 2013 | |
| Michelle Chamuel |
| 29 | Time After Time 2014 REMIX | Apr 2014 | |
| Cyndi Lauper |