blue #
= weekly pop chart peak
| 1 | Where Did Our Love Go | 1 | Jul 1964 |  |
| The Supremes |
| 2 | Where Did Our Love Go | 18 | Nov 1971 | |
| Donnie Elbert |
| 3 | Where Did Our Love Go LIVE | May 1976 | |
| The J. Geils Band |
| 4 | Where Did Our Love Go | Sep 1978 | |
| The Manhattan Transfer |
| 5 | Where Did Our Love Go | Oct 1981 | |
| Helen Cornelius |
| 6 | Where Did Our Love Go | Aug 1982 | |
| Soft Cell |
| 7 | Where Did Our Love Go | May 1985 | |
| The Reddings |
| 8 | Where Did Our Love Go | Apr 1993 | |
| Sinitta |
| 9 | Where Did Our Love Go | Dec 1996 | |
| Tricia Penrose |