| 1 | Chantique De Noel | 1916 |  |
| Enrico Caruso |
| 2 | O Holy Night | Dec 1960 | |
| Nat King Cole with Ralph Carmichael Orchestra |
| 3 | O Holy Night | Dec 1968 | |
| Perry Como |
| 4 | O Holy Night (Minuit Chretien) | Dec 1984 | |
| Luciano Pavarotti |
| 5 | O Holy Night | Dec 1991 | |
| Lou Christie With The University Of Pittsburgh Men's Glee Club |
| 6 | O Holy Night | Dec 1992 | |
| Celine Dion |
| 7 | O Holy Night | Dec 1995 | |
| John Berry |
| 8 | O Holy Night | Dec 1996 | |
| Mariah Carey |
| 9 | O Holy Night | Dec 1996 | |
| Martina McBride |
| 10 | O Holy Night | Dec 2002 | |
| Josh Groban |
| 11 | O Holy Night | Dec 2003 | |
| LeAnn Rimes |
| 12 | O, Holy Night | Dec 2004 | |
| Clay Aiken |
| 13 | O Holy Night | Dec 2004 | |
| BarlowGirl |
| 14 | O Holy Night | Dec 2004 | |
| Shawn McDonald |
| 15 | O Holy Night | Dec 2005 | |
| MercyMe |
| 16 | O Holy Night | Dec 2006 | |
| Third Day |
| 17 | O Holy Night | Dec 2008 | |
| The Priests |
| 18 | O Holy Night | Dec 2008 | |
| Carrie Underwood |
| 19 | O Holy Night | Dec 2010 | |
| The Canadian Tenors |
| 20 | O Holy Night | Dec 2010 | |
| Glee Cast |
| 21 | O Holy Night | Dec 2012 | |
| Sidewalk Prophets |
| 22 | O Holy Night | Dec 2012 | |
| Richard Marx |
| 23 | O Holy Night | Dec 2012 | |
| Rick Springfield |
| 24 | O Holy Night | Dec 2013 | |
| Il Volo |
| 25 | O Holy Night | Dec 2014 | |
| Chris August |
| 26 | O Holy Night | Dec 2014 | |
| Dave Koz Featuring Jonathan Butler |