| 1 | The First Noel | Dec 1958 |  |
| Johnny Mathis |
| 2 | The First Noel | Dec 1963 | |
| Andy Williams |
| 3 | Noel | Dec 1963 | |
| Smokey Robinson & The Miracles |
| 4 | The First Noel | Dec 1966 | |
| Joan Baez |
| 5 | The First Noel | Dec 1975 | |
| Elvis Presley |
| 6 | The First Noel | Dec 1990 | |
| John Denver |
| 7 | The First Noel | Dec 1992 | |
| Crash Test Dummies |
| 8 | The First Noel | Dec 1995 | |
| All-4-One |
| 9 | The First Nowell | Dec 1997 | |
| Eric Johnson |
| 10 | The First Noel | Dec 1998 | |
| Boyz II Men |
| 11 | The First Noel | Dec 2001 | |
| Olivia Newton-John |
| 12 | The First Noel | Dec 2003 | |
| Clay Aiken |
| 13 | The First Noel | Dec 2005 | |
| Twelve Girls Band |
| 14 | The First Noel | Dec 2007 | |
| Boney James |
| 15 | The First Noel | Dec 2007 | |
| Josh Groban With Faith Hill |
| 16 | The First Noel | Dec 2008 | |
| Carrie Underwood |
| 17 | The First Noel | Dec 2008 | |
| Weezer |
| 18 | The First Noel | Dec 2010 | |
| Phil Wickham |
| 19 | The First Noel | Dec 2011 | |
| Jackie Evancho |
| 20 | The First Noel | Dec 2011 | |
| David Crowder Band |
| 21 | The First Noel | Dec 2011 | |
| TobyMac Featuring Owl City |
| 22 | The First Noel | Dec 2013 | |
| Mary J. Blige Featuring The Clark Sisters |