blue #
= weekly pop chart peak
| 1 | You Are My First Love | 1956 |  |
| Ruby Murray |
| 2 | You Are My First Love | Feb 1957 | |
| Nat King Cole with Nelson Riddle Orchestra |
| 3 | First Date, First Kiss, First Love | Apr 1957 | |
| Sonny James |
| 4 | First Love, First Tears | Oct 1959 | |
| Duane Eddy His Twangy Guitar And The Rebels |
| 5 | First Love | Dec 1962 | |
| The Dave Clark Five |
| 6 | First Love Never Dies | Mar 1963 | |
| Claude Gray |
| 7 | First Love | Oct 1980 | |
| Seals & Crofts |
| 8 | My First Love | Oct 1983 | |
| Rene And Angela |
| 9 | First Love | Apr 1989 | |
| Marchello |
| 10 | My First Love | May 1989 | |
| Atlantic Starr |
| 11 | My First Love | Dec 2000 | |
| Avant Featuring Ketara Wyatt |
| 12 | My First Love | Dec 2001 | |
| Kevin Ceballo |
| 13 | My First Love | Jul 2004 | |
| Carl Thomas |
| 14 | First Love | Apr 2006 | |
| Goapele |
| 15 | First Love | Nov 2006 | |
| The Maccabees |
| 16 | My First Love | Mar 2014 | |
| Tony Saunders |
| 17 | First Love | 19 | Jul 2014 | |
| Jennifer Lopez |