blue #
= weekly pop chart peak
| 1 | The First Time | 1961 |  |
| Bonnie Dobson |
| 2 | The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face | 1 | Apr 1972 | |
| Roberta Flack |
| 3 | First Time Ever I Saw Your Face | Oct 1974 | |
| Clams |
| 4 | The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face | Apr 2000 | |
| Celine Dion |
| 5 | The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face | Nov 2007 | |
| Leona Lewis |
| 6 | The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face | Feb 2012 | |
| Glee Cast |